Village for me.
Castle is ok and had some good RE feel to it, but had a major flaw with collect the pieces and run all the way back just to open this door. Everything else was ok, but going through an entire level to collect the items and then running all the way back to the beginning to use them threw me off a little. Plus it got annoying with all the zealots going "Go Hitler, go Hitler, go Hitler." It gets annoying after the first 1,000 times.
Island - Fun and creepy, but I just hate the regenartors when you had the thermal scope, it killed them faster, but sometimes required to kill the plagas all around the stupid monsters.