Oh god! I only played the game once each and still
haha nice. Hopefully, all Rev games will now be canon.
My first playthrough was awesome, I will never forget the feels. Got me hard.
Mass Effect 1 had a awesome soundtrack, the Citadel was huge and had a ton of people to talk to. But it lacked good combat mechanics, and the gameplay was kinda.. flat. About the mako, what made people disapprove it was because it was literally the same thing every single time, only changing the amount of mountains and the skybox of the planets. It got boring over time. Storywise is the best in the series by far, thats why I like it so much.
Mass Effect 2 took out the mako to throw that mining bull****. As I played it dozens of times, I edit my save game always now, to have a ton of minerals and money (the price of the items are super high, and I go crazy if I have to mine all the way to upgrade the ship again). I only play it now because of the romance arcs, because storywise, the plot feels kinda irrelevant to what happens later in the trilogy (its just my opinion, I played this a ****ing lot haha).
Mass Effect 3 was the one I liked most, mainly because of the galactic war theme. The DLCs were great, the characters were perfectly performed, the constant feeling that everything could fall apart.. just awesome. But it had a not so good ending, sadly. But the journey is well worth it.
For me, I'd prefer to have the Collector attack being part of a comic/book(or another game), having ME2 to be the beggining of the Reaper War, then ME3 to portrait the massive conflicts and final stands to destroy the Reaper threat.
In fact, I am replaying ME2 now, it was a long time since last play, soooo its time I got back home
.