I apologize heavily in advance for this being so long...But I have a lot to say on this trilogy...
Rurouni Kenshin: Live Action Films
Live. Action. Anime. Films. A thought that makes a chill run down your spine, as if you were a homicide detective in 1930’s New York, seeing your very first case of someone being sodomized with an Ice Cream Cone. A thought that fills you with such rage, that you feel almost as if you could sue Marvel for creating the Hulk without paying you “Likeness” fees and royalties. For a weeb, Live Action anime films are synonymous with contemplating suicide…BUT!, For my basement dwelling, body pillow clutching brothers and sisters, there is hope. Rurouni Kenshin. Monday night and Tuesday morning, I got together with an old friend to watch all three Live Action Rurouni Kenshin films. And sweet Jesus was I Beyond impressed. If you continue reading past this, it will mostly be spoiler free, with maybe a FEW light spoilers, of what made this film trilogy work in my opinion, as well as why I recommend you giving it a watch.
The first film was made in 2012, and from its opening scene, you know they’re going for a different tone than the anime, which, right off the bat, made me nervous. It very realistically portrays a battle scene. No flashy moves. No unnecessary dialogue or speeches. Just a cold, bloody, war scene, with a damp feeling camera filter, displaying an event from Samurai X. The bleak looking color palette, and horrific violence is something that, while acknowledged was part of life, was rather tame in the anime. Rurouni Kenshin is a Shonen after all. How are you going to make a film about a Shonen, while also keeping it realistic? Easily, apparently. After that scene, it immediately gives us the bright vibrant scenery, more reminiscent of an anime, as it cuts to ten years later. And it. Looks. good. From there, events of the first major arc, everything leading up to the Kyoto arc, plays out relatively normally. Obviously cramming that whole story into 3, two hour movies is difficult, so they make changes. Fortunately, the changes are not bad. Every main character is present, and looks and acts EXACTLY like the should. Sanouske is brash, loud, canstantly smirking, and has a brotherly bond AND rivalry with Kenshin. Kaoru is an idealistic, naive, tomboy who also acts as Kenshin’s guiding light. Saito is a straight forward, no nonsense police officer. These are all wonderfully done characterizations. Not only that, but they even look perfect. I don’t just mean outfits. Their faces, body language, and attitude are all on point as well. And realistic hair! That’s the best part, the hair is a realistic version of their anime hair! Anime hair that doens't look stupid! The costumes are of course great, looking identical to their cartoon counterparts. And costume changes happen often, because again, they go for realism.
Let’s talk about the shows strongest quality. Choreography. It’s a show about a wandering samurai on a path for redemption. So when you hear samurai. You think “Swords.” And god damn do we get a lot of it. Do you guys remember the fight scene in Revenge of the Sith? Between Obi-Wan Kenobi and the sentient plank of wood? Remember how fast and over the top that choreography was. Yeah, this is faster than that, better executed, and often involving more than just two characters. On top of that, rather than using lots of close up and shaky cam to make it look more intense than it is, and hide the fact that it’s cheap and easy, (Looking at you Michael “You F*ck Up Everything Great the 80’s Ever Gave Us” Bay), these movies give us long times without cuts, where you see nearly full bodies at an acceptable distance and angle, to show this is all being done in real time, without the use of effects (In most cases. Notable exception in one instance I won’t explain for spoiler purposes.) Also, all the fighting is done realistically. Kenshin won’t jump 40 feet in the air, and use some special God tier move. However, he does perform realistic versions OF said signature moves. And to make up for the lack of jumping 40 feet, there’s a huge emphasis on almost parkour style movement during the fight scenes. Dare I say, I prefer the movie over the anime if we’re talking STRICTLY action moments.
However, like most films, these are not without their flaws. On the plus side, they’re very few. The first film, is almost perfect. The pacing. The cinematography. The changes they made to the story to streamline certain plot points. However, if you’ve seen the anime, you know there are times where Kenshin will fall back into his Battousai mentality. Usually in very key moments that make the viewer ask moral questions about killing. When this happens, to illustrate the different mindset Kenshin is in, they physically change him in the cartoon. His eyes get more narrowed. His speech pattern changes. I’m pretty sure the eye color even changes a little if I remember right. In the film…He just fights more aggressively. There really isn’t a good way to show that he is a completely different person, without exposition heavy dialogue, which would be an even bigger issue. Thankfully, this movie doesn’t do that. And if you’re familiar with the story, you’ll get what’s going on anyway. It’s just an issue for those that aren’t familiar with the source material. That may sound like a nitpick, but these films actually stand alone. You 100% can and will enjoy them without EVER having touched the manga or the anime.
Nitpick number two, is that neither of the sequel films are paced as well as the first. Don’t get me wrong, they’re still great, but there’s more scenes that lull or drag. And the second is the worst about this. Because of its somber nature, you don’t have those moments of levity that anime often has to cheer you up briefly, even when things are going wrong. The third more or less makes up for a slow build with an explosive finale, that last probably close to 45 minutes. And in my opinion, it actually does this better than the anime because of some changes they've made. Unfortunately, during that finale, Kaoru and Yahiko are severely underutilized. They appear for brief moments, but aren’t 1/100th as focused on as Kenshin, Saito, and Sanouske. In fact, Kenshin’s feelings towards Kaoru as a whole feel a little underdeveloped. Now…that’s not an issue with the dialogue. Any time they are on screen together, you can tell there’s chemistry, and the script is written very well for the two. The films DO have an issue with showing passage of time though. In the anime/manga, everything takes place over the course of about 6 months. In the movie? Presumably the same but I don’t F*ckin know. Could be a couple weeks. We need a better explanation as to why these characters get so chummy so fast.
In conclusion, if you’ve been thinking of watching Rurouni Kenshin, but are too scared to pull the trigger on a long running Shonen like that? Watch the live action movies. You will get almost EVERYTHING you need to, and that will convince you to either watch the show, or to pass on it. If you HAVE already seen Rurouni Kenshin, then definitely f*cking watch this, because it’ll give you new appreciation for live action anime adaptions, as well as hope for more good ones in the future. Hell, you may be like me, and get so enthralled with the choreography, you’ll prefer that aspect of it to the animated alternative. I give the Rurouni Kenshin Trilogy a 9/10