To see if a "movement" is working, you have to look at the fruit. Then you can, by that, judge the roots of it.
Is it working?
Is it achieving the goals?
Is it productive?
Does it benefit others?
Will it stand the test of time and provide a viable framework for future productive movements?
I'm sorry, but right now I'm not seeing a whole lot of good fruit from the current situation. I'm whiter than mayonnaise (and British to boot) so I'll probably never understand it to the extent that others do, especially Black Americans, but even I can see that nothing much is being achieved here.
I'm not even sure what it's about anymore. And if anything, the far left and far right are just feeding their own frenzy with statistics and social media posts and whatever else they can find to whip up more problems than solutions. I've had so many arguments with my daughter about this - she thinks I don't care about black lives because I'm not running to twitter to voice my opinion and I'm not watching every clip on the media.
That's simply not the case.
I merely have zero interest in any movement that cannot clearly define itself and keep order within its own organisation - and, by all accounts, isn't really concerned with who is and who isn't part of it. I struggle to support a movement that hasn't really achieved much at a higher level than a few headlines once every few years and when it does hit the headlines, it's for all the wrong reasons.
I support PEOPLE, not necessarily causes, because it's the people that matter. I couldn't care less if you're purple, but I'm not signing up to a cause just because I'm told I should.
I have no idea how one tackles the institutionalised racism of any country, let alone one that already prides itself of its "wokeness". But trashing the place, ruining lives and twisting agendas to suit is not the way to do it. Because the focus becomes not on the aims of defending and protecting those whose lives are at risk purely because of skin colour...but instead becomes about starting fires, both figurative and literal, and destroying already-decimated communities and lives.
Like I said, I'm white and british - it's a different playbook here, although racism is very much alive and kicking too. So I don't get it and I probably won't get it...but throughout history, successful movements have produced real, lasting fruit. Even when there have been some bad apples amongst it all.
We talk a lot about rights. Not so much about responsibilities. If we focused more on the latter, perhaps the former would become less relevant because it wouldn't be as much of an issue anymore...