Hey guys. Now that this game's been out a while and the dust has settled i figured id give my final thoughts. Iv played through it many times, got all the trophies, read all the files, iv pretty much experienced every thing the game has to offer. Ever since it's reveal this game has split the fanbase in a way iv never seen before, and leading up to it's release i was optimistic. But after playing it im so 50/50 on it. If you say anything bad on this game the first thing you get is " you just don't like the first person". Not at all, thats not the issue. My problem with RE7 is it's total abandoment of the lore. Capcom can sprinkle all the little trinklets in like broken shotguns, green herbs and pictures of the Arklay Mountains that they want, but i have to be honest. When i played RE7 i didnt feel like i was playing in the same world in which i explored the Trevor Mansion, witnessed Raccoon City blowing up, dealt with Nemesis, saved the world from Wesker or fought a giant C Virus dinosaur. I felt like i was playing a reboot. Yes the atmosphere was back, yes the horror was back, yes SOME classic RE tropes like exploration and puzzle's made a come back, but i didnt feel like i was playing a new chapter of the RE canon and that is a real problem.
The gameplay was fine. Playing the game wasn't torture as RE6 sometimes was. The exploration was fun, the combat was satisfying, and the files were welcome. The videotapes were a neat feature but they could have done so much more with it. Imagine finding a happy family tape of the Bakers before Eveline showed up. Jack and Margurites wedding day, Jack teaching Lucas to ride a bike, Margurite and Zoe baking a cake i dunno anything. Something to make you really feel for the Bakers and get you invested. But no we get one 3 minute cutscene with Jack Baker saying " free my family, please" . Dont get me wrong i felt sorry for the guy but Capcom could have done SO much more with this family, especially since the The Bakers are the stars of this game and are the only ones you really remember.
The level design was brilliant, the Baker house felt lived in, the detail was immense and i genuinly did get enjoyment in finding those dogheads while trying to avoid Jack. The swampy old house was fantastic Capcom! Lit only by candles, Margurite wandering around with her lantern, every creak put me on edge, it was great. Every location felt atmospheric and was done with great attention to detail ... theres just not enough of it. When you know what you're doing those dogheads can take you less than 20 minutes to get. I genuinly loved exploring the Baker house but i was left wanting more.
The Boss fights for the most part were good. The first fight with Mia where you lost your hand was genuinly frightening, Jack Baker with the chainsaw was easy but it was fun, Margurite was just a bullet sponge and Jacks final form did mess me up a few times. The end boss was pathetic, just blast away with your machine gun until Eveline drops you and then " Chris" drops you the weapon to finish her. I didnt die once in that fight. Fighting Tyrant, Birkin, Nemesis, Wesker etc i was intimidated. One wrong move and you were done. With Eveline we got a scripted, bullet sponge final boss that was a TOTAL waste.
Overall for me this game had a lot of good and a lot of bad. After Revelations 2 RE7 was not what i expected in the slightest, i always envisioned RE7 as a Jill game, with the world recovering from the C virus and maybe some Alex/ Natalia. RE7 wasn't a painful game to play and it did have some moments of brilliance, but i can't forgive it for totally abandoning the lore and ignoring previous unresolved stories. Hate RE5 and 6 all you want, but to me i felt like i was playing Resident Evil more than i did with RE7, and NOT because of the first person perspective.