Never got around to posting my opinion on the game in detail, and I’ll do that later, but for this thread, gotta say, I could not disagree more. This absolutely is a Resident Evil game. The definition of what that means hasn’t really been nailed down, but I’ll do so as closely as possible here. A Resident Evil game is not required to be Survival Horror, involve puzzle solving, have non-linear gameplay, have a specific control scheme, or involve zombies. A Resident Evil game, simply put, only needs to be a horror-based game set within the continuity established by the original game, and the horror is generated by contagious biological sources. That’s it.
This game had that. Contrary to the OP, you can indeed explain away the “supernatural” aspects of this game to scientific experiments. The series has been doing that the entire time, all the way back to the original, what with reanimated corpses and creatures that defy the laws of physics. Really, the only things in this game that come across as overtly supernatural are Donna’s hauntings (hallucinations, already done in Revelations), Miranda’s shapeshifting (already done in Zero and 6), and Heisenberg’s metal manipulation, which is explained as just an electrical field his body is generating that he’s learned to increase or decrease in just the right way to knock away or attract metallic objects (electricity manipulation, while not yet of this magnitude, was already tapped into in Dead Aim). None of those come close to the impossibly bonkers hoop-jumping needed to explain how Derek Simmons’ mutations in 6 worked.
The Umbrella connection, while a bit jarring, doesn’t really change anything except show why Spencer chose when he did to start his exposition to look for Progenitor, why he was sure his efforts could work, and where he got the idea for Umbrella’s name and look.
All the other unanswered questions, such as the Connections, what the BSAA are up to, why Chris is going rogue, where Blue Umbrella fits in, etc., is clearly meant to be addressed in a later game, just as several questions about the Mold were answered in this game.
It’s scary, it’s conspiracy-laden, it involves the same characters and storyline, it’s all biology-driven due to mad science… it’s Resident Evil. And while Village is not one of the greats (REmake, 4 (original), 7) it’s definitely one of the heavies (2, Code Veronica, 5).