Oh my god, FINALLY, someone who is able to think reasonably when it comes to the games vs. the movies. I agree 100% with all that you've said, all of it. I enjoy both the games and the movies a lot. To me, Afterlife was the most rushed and sloppily put together in the series. I liked the first one and Apocalypse best.
I honestly can't form any theories as of right now about Retribution. All I know is that it will be jammed-packed full of content and intersecting plot points from what I saw in the trailer. Apparently we're going to be traveling around the world; Washington DC to Moscow, while also retreading the events of Raccoon City.
It totally CANNOT be flashbacks, because Rain, Carlos, and One are all back as both villains AND normal everyday people! Minus One. In the trailer, we see the everyday Rain a mess, completely terrified, holding up the GUN ALICE HAS IN RETRIBUTION.
NOT TO MENTION Ada seems to be in a normal neighborhood, and then later, we see the new Alice WITH Ada. Then, we see the new Alice IN Tokyo, where Afterlife started.
And apparently, Alice is working for Umbrella, unless she's a clone! This is supported by a twitter video Milla shot where she was in some sort of skin-tight testing uniform. And then we're shown images of Alice in her Afterlife costume on the Arcadia, right where Retribution starts!
Then, throw Luther, Leon, and Barry into the mix, AS WELL AS Jill and Wesker as villains.
I think I speak for everyone when I say WHAT IS GOING ON?! The world is apparently simultaneously in a monster-infested apocalyptic world, AND a normal suburban world!
I am so pumped for this movie.