First off...You're exactly right about FFXIII...kennedy killer, youtube alphaomegasin,he appreciates all games and still plays games from way back when, and understands what a true gamer is.
you guys are right about the cod fanbase, they are still gamers,but they are, as you say restricted.
one thing i get sick of hearing today is, people who trash a game just because it doesn't have todays graphics, i mean i still play ps1 games on emulator along with dreamcast games and i can see past the shoddy graphics and appreciate a game for what it is, and if i still had my n64 i would totally play it (ocarina of time FTW)
todays generation of gamers, only really class a game as good, if it's an FPS, has explosive graphics and doesn't really have any sense of a story line. and that makes me sick.
because of this growing fan base, more game companys are throwing out games to copy cod because that's what sells at the moment...but what about a decent rpg (and don't for the love of god anyone say, "well we do have final fantasy 13..NO, that game just about passes as a final fantasy game, after they ruined the battle system and slapped a linear progression path on it)
Second off, that's why I love the Wii so much...It had SO many good games (5 different RE games, Mario, Zelda, Smash Bros, Sonic, Obscure, ect.) and yes, they didn't have the graphics of the PS3 or 360, but it NEVER took away from the fun...In fact...If I remember correctly, the FPS game with the best graphics on the Wii was fu-king Metroid...Which was STILL an awesome game...
I'm with ya...I play loads of older game systems despite the graphics...I still play Super Nintendo, Gamecube, XBox, Genesis, PS1...They're all great, despite not having brand new games and cutting edge graphics...I wish I still had my Dreamcast..That's my all time favorite system...