After looking through previous topics, I couldn't find this exact topic - but I thought since this conversation is naturally occurring in other threads, we may as well make it it's own thing.
Here are my personal SH Rankings (Haven't played Downpour yet!)
1. Silent Hill 3 - The art work is the biggest reason I put this game on top. It looks so gross and so amazing at the same time. Every location is fraught with imagery that evokes different levels of emotions. I think the story could be adapted a little further, but man is it fun to be Heather and look to come to SH for vengeance.
2. Silent Hill 2 - The most popular game in the series for good reason. Still one of the best stories in video game history and every side character/moment/event/monster adds to the theme. This is the most focused a Silent Hill game can be. And Pyramid Head is still scary - even after playing through the games probably 4 or 5 times.
3. Silent Hill 1 - The first game in the series. When you go back to it - it looks so dated - but man, the story is in tact. When I first played it, I thought it couldn't possibly be as scary as Resident Evil 2. But man, was I ****ing wrong. It brought scares. And the emotional value of the ending still resonates with me.
4. Silent Hill 4: The Room - I HATE First Person, so I did not want to play this game for so long - but I am glad I have it a shot. Once again, a top notch story even if it is a little loose in terms of connection to Silent Hill. Another great presentation of art, horror, and a high creep factor. People hate on Henry for being dull. But I like his Dimitri Martin looking ass. My biggest gripe with the game is that you have to visit the same locations so many times.
5. Silent Hill: ****tered Memories - This is the SH game I have played the most. If you don't know about this game - it is a slight re-imagining of the first game except there are only a few varied enemy types and long chase sequences. It is a mystery of a game and it is deeply innovative on a psychological level. The game evolves the enemies and minor details based on choices you make in separate therapy sessions and in the game. The twist at the end is beyond words. And getting the different endings is pretty fun.
6. Silent Hill Origins - EDIT: Completely forgot about Origins which is probably NOT a good sign. But I still enjoyed the game. This is a game that feels like they were TRYING to make a Silent Hill game and a lot of the decisions ended up just being weird. But the game is quick to play through and fun too. It fights with the story canon of the original game, but I still played it through probably 4 or 5 times just to see all of the unlockables. So it can't be that bad!
7. Silent Hill Homecoming - What is great about this game is the level of detail in the enemies. They are some of the creepiest in the series and the battle mechanics are difficult adding to the tension. But the game feels like a fan game and not in the best way. It feels very forced. I don't think it is a bad game, but it didn't capture the innovations of the other installments. The team that developed the game went too far in to the action realm and SH fanboy theories to make this game great. But like any RE game, it is still a good game.
Let me know if you agree/disagree and let me know what you think!
Here are my personal SH Rankings (Haven't played Downpour yet!)
1. Silent Hill 3 - The art work is the biggest reason I put this game on top. It looks so gross and so amazing at the same time. Every location is fraught with imagery that evokes different levels of emotions. I think the story could be adapted a little further, but man is it fun to be Heather and look to come to SH for vengeance.
2. Silent Hill 2 - The most popular game in the series for good reason. Still one of the best stories in video game history and every side character/moment/event/monster adds to the theme. This is the most focused a Silent Hill game can be. And Pyramid Head is still scary - even after playing through the games probably 4 or 5 times.
3. Silent Hill 1 - The first game in the series. When you go back to it - it looks so dated - but man, the story is in tact. When I first played it, I thought it couldn't possibly be as scary as Resident Evil 2. But man, was I ****ing wrong. It brought scares. And the emotional value of the ending still resonates with me.
4. Silent Hill 4: The Room - I HATE First Person, so I did not want to play this game for so long - but I am glad I have it a shot. Once again, a top notch story even if it is a little loose in terms of connection to Silent Hill. Another great presentation of art, horror, and a high creep factor. People hate on Henry for being dull. But I like his Dimitri Martin looking ass. My biggest gripe with the game is that you have to visit the same locations so many times.
5. Silent Hill: ****tered Memories - This is the SH game I have played the most. If you don't know about this game - it is a slight re-imagining of the first game except there are only a few varied enemy types and long chase sequences. It is a mystery of a game and it is deeply innovative on a psychological level. The game evolves the enemies and minor details based on choices you make in separate therapy sessions and in the game. The twist at the end is beyond words. And getting the different endings is pretty fun.
6. Silent Hill Origins - EDIT: Completely forgot about Origins which is probably NOT a good sign. But I still enjoyed the game. This is a game that feels like they were TRYING to make a Silent Hill game and a lot of the decisions ended up just being weird. But the game is quick to play through and fun too. It fights with the story canon of the original game, but I still played it through probably 4 or 5 times just to see all of the unlockables. So it can't be that bad!
7. Silent Hill Homecoming - What is great about this game is the level of detail in the enemies. They are some of the creepiest in the series and the battle mechanics are difficult adding to the tension. But the game feels like a fan game and not in the best way. It feels very forced. I don't think it is a bad game, but it didn't capture the innovations of the other installments. The team that developed the game went too far in to the action realm and SH fanboy theories to make this game great. But like any RE game, it is still a good game.
Let me know if you agree/disagree and let me know what you think!
Last edited: