The game lacks a variety of creatures. They got one thing right, though: They gave us a new main character. That's something I yearned for long ago. When they have the same characters over and over again in horror media, then everything gradually gets to be the polar opposite of creepy.
I hate gaming sin videos. They're a straight rip from cinema sins which is unfitting since that's a plot deconstruction series. If you're going to deconstruct a game then your focus should be the game, or at least the story and the game, not just the story.